March 18, 2008
Posted by Ryan Graves
Learning vs. Doing
There is something that I’ve been struggling with a great deal recently and an article I read tonight by Paul Graham made the struggle even worse. The issue originated from my decisions surrounding what I should be reading, how I should be spending my “develop Ryan time” and what sort of further education I should pursue. The struggle I’ve been facing is this, “is it more important to know how to do or to do.”
This struggle also ties back to the motivation behind my other blog ActionsTalk. Often times I find myself discussing ideas, learning how to implement new ideas, and working to further develop those ideas but not as often do I find myself acting on those ideas. Maybe action is the significantly more important piece.
The example that comes most easily to mind is a web app. I always seem to have great ideas around new web solutions for all kinds of different life and business problems but I much less (almost never) find myself trying to develop (in the coding sense not the growth sense) these new ideas/applications. In this scenario I often question if I’m spending my time wisely. Just because I’ve read about hundreds of start-ups, tested hundreds of start-ups tools and apps, and could easily tell you all the do’s and the do not’s of starting a start up company doesn’t mean I’m any closer to starting one.
Paul Graham’s conclusion in the article was disturbing in that I’ve spent a lot of time trying to understand many of the how’s and what’s of the start-up process such as how to obtain funding, how do I choose a language and what are the capabilities of that language, and what are the most profitable idea industries. I haven’t spend as much of my time learning the languages, writing the code or actually “creating” anything. Paul’s contention is that you don’t need to know “business” to succeed in this process. You don’t need to know the process before you dive in. Well I’ve been spending much of my time on understanding and learning the process. If Paul is right, then that’s scary.
Maybe it’s time I stopped worrying about the start up industry. Maybe it is time that I pick up that PHP/MySQL book by my bed that’s practically unopened and begin to dive into the doing, the coding, the ever so important creation phase of this process. The learning will not stop it will just change. Now I believe the learning will be more applicable and a bit less theoretical.
Anyone who has gone through the process of transitioning from “reading about” to “doing”, I would love to hear your feedback on the experience and what conclusions you drew on Paul Graham’s theory.





2 Comments
March 19, 2008
Hey Bud! This is a very wise thought! I have constantly struggled with this idea as I teach Bible study. What good does it do to just read the Bible, put it down, and go away unchanged. That is why the emphasis I have always had on teaching is “application.” You must ask, “What does this mean to me?” “How can I make this a part of my life?” That is why Jesus taught in parables – so that the people could understand what he was saying. They understood that seed had to be planted in good soil that would accept it and be watered for it to grow. He meant that His good Word had to go into their hearts, be considered, and applied to cause growth in their lives. The cares of the world (tough ground or weeds) make that very difficult!
I constantly struggle to find relevant stories, poems, quotes, and daily experiences that will cause my listeners to desire to look for ways in their lives to “live the Word.” With each year I teach I see more and more women whose lives have been changed for the better because they have been successful with that.
I applaud you for looking for ways to be a “doer” and not just a “listener” (also Biblical, you know! James 1:22)! I believe that you can “live the dream” by being balanced in your life. Read the stuff, learn how to do the stuff, then live the stuff, enjoy the stuff, and help others to live and learn.
“Just do it!” :)
So – enjoy your “develop Ryan time!”
April 2, 2008
Hey Ryan,
Good point you raise.
It is not an either/or question (so very few ever are).
Learning and doing go hand in hand. When you step into a new field, there is a period where all you do is read about it, talk about, even theorize about it. This is ok, as long as you are aware of what you are actually doing. Just don’t fool yourself thinking you KNOW. At that point, you know nothing. You are just learning.
You can only KNOW by doing. From what you say you have hit that point, so get your hands dirty if you must. No more reading will help you much now. Get the programming books and start coding. Or get the money and start outsourcing. Just make sure there is an output to your actions.
Even when we get good at something, if we stop doing it, we stop truly knowing it. It’s like those fat doctors giving diet advice: how seriously can you take them?
Getting our daily dosis of reading is great IMO. We just need to be aware it is a means to an end: EFFECTIVE ACTION!
Leave a comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.